Indie game news, reviews, previews and everything else concerning indie game development.

14
Comments

The Finals: Shattered Horizon vs. Dwarf Fortress [Tournament]

DIYbracketstart004

This is it. After launching this tournament waaay back in April, we are finally drawing it to a close. Today marks the start of the Finals, after the semi-finals concluded yesterday. But before we get into that, let’s go over the results.

First, we have a had surprise outcome in the Shattered Horizon vs. Torchlight tournament match up. Honestly, I was expecting Torchlight to handily defeat Shattered Horizon and, in fact, for the first half of the week it was. However, slowly, but surely, the Shattered Horizon community just kept pushing forward, making strides, and eventually eking out a victory over Torchlight. The end result was 51.74% to 48.26%. Great effort by both communities involved.

Next, we had Dwarf Fortress vs. Spelunky. Arguably two of the indiest of indie games to get released. The match up started off well enough, with both games trading places quite frequently. However, it seems like the Spelunky community just didn’t have the gears to keep the momentum going and Dwarf Fortress pulled ahead by a healthy margin. The end result was 61.62% for Dwarf Fortress to 38.38% for Spelunky. Great effort by both games, truly.

And so here we are. We’ve got our trophy, we’ve got our two finalist competitors, and now we’ve got our final. There’s nothing more I can say about these games that you don’t already know at this point. Both are fantastic in their own right, and both truly sought to do something amazing with their game.

Two things before I get to the tournament:

1. You’ll notice this is a BLIND tournament. We’ve done this to generally ensure that everything is fun and fair. This is the final, after all, and we want to make sure there are no more controversies like in the past. Don’t worry, though, as soon as the tournament concludes, we’ll simply flip the switch and you can see the exact percentage and total votes cast in the Final.

2. The Final match-up is running from today until Wednesday the 14th. Unfortunately I have scheduling conflicts for the latter part of next week, so this contest will be a day shorter, but it should still be fun regardless.

Here is your Final Match Up:


ShatteredvsDwarfFortress

UPDATE! Wow… I am so sorry for the delay in announcing the winner. It just so happened my internet crapped out on me the day before the announcement and then I had a vacation planned for the day after and, up until this point, I did not have any access to the internet at all. It’s been crazy, hectic, and above all else, infuriating. Especially since non of the other writers have access to the polling account. So, I’m terribly sorry for any inconveniences this caused. This is our first year running the tournament and mistakes were bound to happen. The winners should be available to see now.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Comments

  • Logan

    It’s interesting to see a modern-graphics game matched with a pixel art based one.

    Kind of appropriate :P Indies come in all shapes and sizes.

  • TheAngryMongoose

    We really won’t get to see how this is going til it’s over? Damn…

  • Luminaflare

    Logan it’s not pixel art, it’s all text in different colours. Also known as ASCII

  • Logan

    I still see that as pixel art imo, just how I think. :D

  • davmcm

    Gotta respect the complexity of dwarf fortress, but shattered horizon is work of art. its a stunning game and should be recognised for bringing beautiful graphics together with well refined gameplay as well as pushing gamers forward into DX10 territory.

  • http://moonloop.vg Eclipse

    Dwarf Fortress is an ambitious game, but it has lackluster GUI, and I’m a long time roguelike player. That gui is just horrible D:
    I’d gladly vote for it if the developers cared a little about designing a very deep and complex game but with a friendly user interface

  • http://moonloop.vg Eclipse

    On the other hand, Shattered Horizon is an awesome fps and I voted for it all the way up the final so there goes my vote

  • bill stelling

    ok… so who won??

  • Erik Johnson

    I’m sure Geoff will have a grand announcement here soon.

  • hillie_o

    Waiting on pins and needles…

  • blueyes77

    I love these tournaments, after winning that Torchlight, i got hooked to it:D

    Congrats to who ever wins, i want to test also that DF:)

  • Too Old 4 This Sh**

    Who won????????????
    Come on guys, I am checking this site every day!!!

  • blueyes77

    Congratulations FM!!!!! You have deserved this WIN!!

    I love SH!

  • Too Old 4 This ****

    thanx for posting this, congratulations to FGS, and the whole SH community!!!